Why I'm Still Holding off on the MacBook Pro 19

Posted by jason

1. BluRay – 25GB & 50GB recording capabilities for completely backing up my hard drive on 2 BluRay discs. Sony just put its $3,499 BluRay laptop up for pre-release sale, so Apple should follow by January MacWorld, at the latest.

2. Robson – 64MB-4GB Flash memory for booting in seconds, rather than half a minute. Availability: next year.

3. 802.11n (forgot this one!) – The promise is for bandwidth rates of up to 540mbps, which is cool – but not that useful, since we’re limited by the speed of the cable/DSL connection, but not bad for internal data transfers. The important piece is the 2-8x increase in range. Sweet.

4. Maturity – In the 5 months since the Pro came out, and Apple has had more than 4 revisions (2 months ago, they were on Revision E). Over time, Apple works out kinks in each revision – such as fan noise.

5. Important Universal Binaries – A lot of my company’s work requires the Adobe Suite, and the Universal Binary that will come with Adobe CS 3 won’t be available until 2007. Speed is your friend, and running CS2 on a 2 Ghz MacBook under Rosetta is 60% slower than on a 12” Powerbook. Blechhh.

6. Virtualization – VMWare is releasing its software in the next 6 months for OS X, although Parallels just went Gold. I’ll look out for reviews of the last version, although the last release candidate wasn’t stable.

7. Buyer’s remorse – I bought my 17” PowerBook in November. Ouch. I bought the 15” Titanium, 3 months before the 17” Powerbook came out, in November. I got the 17” Powerbook in November 2005, 3 months before the 15” MacBook Pro came out. Ouch. Steve Jobs knows when I’m about to buy a new laptop, and hates me. Punk.

7. Leopard & iLife 07’ – Save $129 on a next-generation OS and $79 on iLife. I’m guessing Leopard availability in Summer 07’ and January 07’ for iLife. Ok, this one’s really just more buyer’s remorse :-).

Comments

Leave a response

  1. MikeJune 16, 2006 @ 09:03 AM
    Parallels is working quite well. Zero stability issues for me. Simply works (like all Mac software should).
  2. Mark SJune 16, 2006 @ 09:25 AM
    It seems the technology is changing so fast on all fronts, one can't wait and wait, as every year, as there are new and hot items coming out all the time. What about the quad chips? I understand those may be initially for servers, but they will migrate to portables. I'd like to wait for a MacBook with a quad chip, but I may have to wait quite a while! LOL
  3. JamieJune 16, 2006 @ 09:44 AM
    For Point 1, Mirra (now Seagate) just released a Mac client. It does automated real-time backup. I've used it to restore a HD already; worked great. Only downside: it's not a true network file server. "Seagate's Mirra Sync and Share Personal Server is the next generation of the award-winning Mirra Personal Server 2.0. The Mirra Sync and Share offers long awaited Macintosh compatibility, making it the best way to sync, share and protect data between Macs and PCs."
  4. MylesJune 16, 2006 @ 12:40 PM
    There is only one valid reason to buy: you need it now. There is only one valid reason to wait: you don't need it now.
  5. kboggsJune 16, 2006 @ 01:27 PM
    Ditto on Parallels. It runs great. Give it a shot.
  6. Happy PhantomJune 16, 2006 @ 09:37 PM
    I was waiting for Leopard, too. Tiger from Panther was rough for me. I was also thinking that Intel's Merom (Core 2 Duo) will arrive in August or September. The Macbook Pro will get this 2.8Ghz chip immdiately. Then I realized I didn't want a Pro, but a black Macbook. I don't think it will get the Core 2 until January. Didn't make sense to wait six or seven months. Bought mine today from Macmall.
  7. niksterJune 16, 2006 @ 11:14 PM
    My reasons for holding off: In 6 months, there's going to be a new version which is faster and costs the same! What a scandal ;)
  8. tacobellJune 18, 2006 @ 02:32 AM
    I started reviewing new video cameras in 1986, and they keep getting better - i am still holding off for the new features, higher res, better image stabilization, faster frame rate, etc. I am sure I will buy soon. DOH!!!!

    Virtualization - What???? It's here, get on the train. What are you talking about in #6????

    Blu-Ray? #1? fracking lame as a #1. Get a damn external when you need it. It's a $1000 consumer player that really isn't shipping in bulk, and the laptop drives don't yet work well (see gearlog.com). You want apple to drop that in a macbook and raise the price by nearly $1000, which is their cost to sony? Oh yeah, did we forget... format wars. Let the battle shake out, then, when a dual format drive is on the market, have apple drop it in the laptops.

    Robson is great - give it some time to mature, it's not vital to drop that immature tech into all laptops immediately - plus it's an OS issue too - when is Vista shipping, Jan'07? maybe! And maybe 10.5 will incorporate flash booting. (See your other comments about maturity.)

    What happened to #3

    #5 - my main reason was lack of VPC support, but bootcamp and parallels turned turned that in HUGE a positive. UBs were the other reason - since I am not a PS jockey, I can live with CS2 for now, and Office is reasonably fast. What I will wait for is the Core Duo 2, and the next gen desktop.

    #4 - you have argued yourself into buying now - they are on Rev E, so most of the bugs are gone, great time to buy, before they go to Core Duo 2 and start with a RevA mobo.
  9. tacobellJune 18, 2006 @ 02:33 AM
    too bad there aren't any paragraph returns in this software - my last post was beautiful.
  10. Jason WongJune 18, 2006 @ 08:45 AM
    It was beautiful. You actually need to use the br or p tag to get paragraphs in there, so I put them in.

    I renumbered the posting as well - that must have slipped past my immense editorial staff ;-).

    To be honest, most my reason for holding off is probably the buyer's remorse issue - but I think I will wait for BluRay, as it's one of the technology jumps that only occur once every 5-10 years.

    Oh, I will add another one. Refer to post above, and you'll see the edits.

    There haven't been any reviews for the release version of parallels, although the comments are saying the thing's great. It's making me drool.

    #4 You're right in that it's probably mostly stable. Core Duo 2 is a jump to 2.8 Ghz. Now THAT makes my mouth water.
  11. ErickJune 18, 2006 @ 10:54 AM
    I got the 17" Powerbook in November 2005, 3 months before the 15" MacBook Pro came out. Ouch. Steve Jobs knows when I'm about to buy a new laptop, and hates me. Punk.

    If you wait 6 months for a model to mature before buying it, then naturally the next generation will come out within another 3 months, right?

  12. Jason WongJune 18, 2006 @ 08:04 PM
    These are complete revisions - the move from Titanium PowerBook to Aluminum PowerBook, and the move from Aluminum PowerBook to MacBook. That's why it hurts more.
  13. NickJune 20, 2006 @ 12:32 AM
    The figures being quoted for Creative Suite 2 on Intel are way off the mark, at least for Photoshop. I have been running a MacBook Pro alongside other machines for a couple of months and my own 'Real world' timings has confirmed my suspicions; that performance is more than acceptable. Substantially faster than the last Powerbooks and roughly on a par with a dual 2Ghz G5. Nick.
  14. TresspasserrerierOctober 19, 2006 @ 02:14 AM
    It's already in later-mid October. Are you still holding it off? My MBP is already a half a year old! Definitely much better MBP will be already out next year around the same time now anyways~
  15. NickOctober 19, 2006 @ 02:18 AM
    Core 2 Duo may consume less power per performance, but high performance still means more power. Core 2 Duo will not gain much performance over Core Duo anyways. Wait until Core 3 Duo comes out! Or even Core 4 or 5 Duo if you like waiting.
  16. pozycjonowanie stron wwwSeptember 19, 2007 @ 10:59 PM
    very good reasons
  17. 8MMSeptember 20, 2007 @ 11:33 PM
    Wow, you have two reasons number 7 :)
  18. Nieruchomo?ci SzczecinSeptember 24, 2007 @ 02:25 PM
    I was waiting for Leopard in Polen. Waiting.....
  19. TomeyNovember 11, 2007 @ 04:21 PM
    MacBook Pro is such a beauftul thing, i own one and can recommend you all to get one!
Comment